Introduction
When it comes to problem management in organizations, the first thought is usually to solve them. However, it’s not always that straightforward. In reality, companies and individuals often respond to problems in three distinct ways without necessarily solving them: by shifting, preserving, or creating new problems. These responses may seem counterintuitive, but they play a crucial role in organizational dynamics.
Shifting Problems
Shifting a problem involves moving it away from its initial context without truly solving it. This often occurs in large organizations where continuous improvement projects are implemented. For example, enhancing the efficiency of one department by increasing the burden on another. A McKinsey report (2023) reveals that over 60% of change initiatives fail due to problem shifting rather than resolution.
Real-world Example
Consider a tech company that improves its customer service by reducing phone wait times. However, this revision leads to an overload of request processing systems, creating a new problem. The key lies in optimizing processes holistically rather than making local adjustments.
Preserving Problems
According to the Shirky Principle, institutions tend to preserve the problems for which they are supposed to be the solution. This may seem paradoxical but is often driven by personal or organizational interests. A Deloitte report (2022) indicates that 70% of companies retain inefficient processes due to resistance to change and fear of the unknown.
Use Case
Consider a consulting firm benefiting from inefficiencies in a specific industry. Solving these inefficiencies could reduce the demand for its services, prompting the firm to maintain the status quo. To overcome this inertia, it is crucial to align incentives to encourage innovation and efficiency.
Promoting New Problems
Solving a problem can often create another, a well-known phenomenon in technology project management. Neil Postman highlighted that each solution generates new challenges. According to a MIT study, 50% of tech projects create unexpected problems requiring additional solutions.
Illustration
Imagine a company introducing AI to automate repetitive tasks. While this increases efficiency, it can also lead to issues related to data management and cybersecurity. Thus, proactive risk management becomes essential to avoid new problems.
Conclusion
Understanding these three responses to problems is essential for any organization seeking to navigate the complex modern business environment effectively. Rather than merely solving problems, it is crucial to design strategies to prevent shifting, preserving, or promoting new problems.
Let's discuss your project in 15 minutes.