← Retour au blog
tech 30 May 2026

"But it happened." - Casey Muratori's Comment on Eric Schmidt's Commencement Speech

Casey Muratori reacted skeptically to Eric Schmidt's commencement speech, highlighting the gap between technological promises and their realization. Let's dive into this critique and analyze its impact on the tech world.

Introduction

When Eric Schmidt, former CEO of Google, delivered a commencement address, he left a strong impression on many with ambitious ideas about the future of technology. However, Casey Muratori, a video game developer and outspoken critic of tech trends, responded with a simple phrase: "But it happened." This response, while succinct, raises fundamental questions about the gap between technological predictions and their real-world materialization.

Eric Schmidt's Speech

In his speech, Eric Schmidt shared an inspiring vision of the future, where technology would solve some of humanity's greatest challenges. He spoke about artificial intelligence (AI) as a tool to enhance everyone's life, promising an era where machines and humans would work in harmony to accomplish complex tasks and free up time for human creativity.

However, this idealistic vision has often been criticized for its excessive optimism. For instance, the 2023 "State of AI" report shows that while AI has progressed, it is far from reaching a level of understanding and autonomy close to that of humans. In 2022, only 15% of companies surveyed by McKinsey reported having integrated AI into their core operations, indicating that adoption is still hesitant and uneven.

Casey Muratori's Perspective

Casey Muratori, known for his YouTube series "Handmade Hero" where he shares video game development insights, has often criticized the hype surrounding technology. His comment "But it happened" can be interpreted as a caution against the tendency to promise more than technology can actually deliver.

Muratori highlights that several technologies announced as revolutionary have yet to materialize or have failed to meet their initial promises. Take virtual reality technology, for example, which despite significant advances, has yet to reach the market penetration many envisioned a decade ago.

The Unfulfilled Promises of Technology

Unfulfilled promises are not new in the tech world. Examples abound: flying cars, promised since the 1960s, remain a curiosity more than a practical reality. Similarly, blockchain, though having successful applications, has yet to disrupt all sectors as some had predicted.

These unrealized promises can be attributed to a multitude of factors, including technical challenges, regulatory issues, and a lack of public adoption. A 2023 CB Insights report showed that 70% of startups generally fail due to these obstacles.

Impact on Decision Makers and Entrepreneurs

For decision-makers and entrepreneurs, Muratori's message is clear: it is crucial to have a critical view of technological predictions and to focus on what is achievable today. Innovation requires time, patience, and a clear understanding of current technological limitations.

Adopting a more pragmatic approach can help avoid the pitfalls of technological hyperbole and focus on developments that actually add value. For instance, implementing AI to automate repetitive administrative tasks in a business can offer a tangible and measurable return on investment.

Conclusion

Casey Muratori's remark serves as a reminder to tech players that while innovation dreams are important, it is essential to keep our feet on the ground. To build a sustainable technological future, we must balance optimism with reality. So, instead of chasing the latest trends, focus on what can truly be accomplished today.

Let's discuss your project in 15 minutes.

Casey Muratori Eric Schmidt technologie promesses non tenues innovation
Deepthix newsletter · 100% AI · every Monday 8am

An AI agent reads tech for you.

Our AI agent scans ~200 sources per week and ships the best articles to your inbox Monday 8am. Free. One click to unsubscribe.

Visit the newsletter page →

Want to automate your operations?

Let's talk about your project in 15 minutes.

Book a call